Toyota Highlander vs Acadia: Which SUV Is Better?
When looking for midsize SUVs, drivers have to choose between the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia. These vehicles are great for families. They offer comfort, performance, and reliability on American roads.
The debate between Highlander and Acadia focuses on two top SUVs. They are perfect for city driving or weekend trips. These SUVs mix practicality with excitement.
We’ll compare key features that buyers care about. This includes performance, technology, safety, and value. We aim to highlight each vehicle’s strengths to guide your choice.
Families and drivers will find useful information here. Knowing the differences between Highlander and Acadia can make buying a car easier. It turns a daunting task into a confident decision.
Overview of Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia
The midsize SUV market has many great options for families and those who love adventure. The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia are two top picks. They offer great performance, comfort, and versatility for today’s drivers.
Model Years and Generations
The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia have changed a lot over the years. The Highlander started in 2001 and has had four big updates. Now, it’s a mix of the latest tech and design.
- Toyota Highlander: Introduced in 2001
- Current Generation: Fifth generation (2020-present)
- GMC Acadia: First introduced in 2007
- Current Generation: Third generation (2017-present)
Market Position and Target Audience
These SUVs aim at different parts of the midsize market. The Highlander is for families who want reliability and practicality. The Acadia is for those who want a more luxurious drive.
| Characteristic | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia |
|---|---|---|
| Primary Market | Family-oriented buyers | Luxury-focused consumers |
| Key Strengths | Reliability, Fuel Efficiency | Premium Features, Performance |
Brand Heritage and Reputation
Toyota and GMC have their own special places in the SUV world. Toyota is known for being reliable and holding its value well. GMC is famous for its strong build and premium look.
- Toyota: Known for long-lasting vehicles
- GMC: Recognized for professional-grade engineering
- Both brands maintain strong customer loyalty
The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia show two different ways to tackle the midsize SUV market. They give people many choices based on their lifestyle and what they like.
Price Comparison and Value Proposition
When looking for midsize SUVs with third-row seating, price matters. The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia show different values. It’s not just about the price you pay.
The starting MSRPs show an interesting comparison:
- Toyota Highlander: Starts at $41,315
- GMC Acadia: Starts at $44,495
The GMC Acadia costs more, but it has special premium features. These might make the extra cost worth it. Think about what each car offers in terms of seating.
Important things to consider include:
- Standard equipment
- Warranty coverage
- Long-term ownership expenses
- Potential maintenance costs
The Toyota Highlander is a good deal for those watching their budget. It’s reliable and has flexible seating. It’s a smart choice for families.
Smart shoppers look beyond the initial price and evaluate total ownership value.
Engine Performance and Power Delivery
When comparing the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia, engine performance is key. Both SUVs offer impressive power, each with its own strengths. These strengths meet different driving needs and preferences.
Engine Specifications
The powertrain options for these SUVs show different engineering approaches. The 2025 GMC Acadia has a turbocharged 2.5L engine. It delivers 328 horsepower and 326 lb.-ft. of torque.
In contrast, the Toyota Highlander has a 2.4L turbocharged engine. It makes 265 horsepower and 310 lb.-ft. of torque.
Acceleration and Handling
Performance lovers will enjoy the unique driving feel of both SUVs. The Acadia’s higher horsepower means quicker acceleration. The Highlander offers a smooth and balanced drive.
Key performance features include:
- Responsive throttle response
- Smooth power delivery
- Precise steering dynamics
- Stable cornering capabilities
Towing Capabilities
Towing is a big deal for many SUV buyers. The Acadia outshines in this area, with better towing capacity. It’s great for hauling trailers, boats, or recreational gear.
| Vehicle | Horsepower | Torque | Towing Capacity |
|---|---|---|---|
| GMC Acadia | 328 hp | 326 lb.-ft. | 5,000 lbs |
| Toyota Highlander | 265 hp | 310 lb.-ft. | 3,500 lbs |
For those who value performance and towing, the GMC Acadia is a strong choice. It offers power, efficiency, and versatility.
Fuel Economy and Efficiency Ratings
Fuel efficiency is key for SUV buyers looking at the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia. Both have good performance numbers. These numbers affect how much you’ll spend over time and the environment.
The Toyota Highlander shows great fuel economy. Here’s what drivers can expect:
- City driving: 22 miles per gallon
- Highway driving: 29 miles per gallon
- Good performance in all trim levels
The GMC Acadia has slightly lower fuel efficiency:
- City driving: 20 miles per gallon
- Highway driving: 27 miles per gallon
- Numbers vary with engine choices
Fuel efficiency differences may seem small, but they add up over time. The Toyota Highlander is 2-3 MPG better. This could save hundreds of dollars a year for many drivers.
Smart SUV buyers see fuel efficiency as a long-term investment. It’s about saving money and being kind to the planet.
For the best fuel efficiency, consider the Highlander’s hybrid model. It has even better numbers. This makes it a great choice for those who care about the environment.
Exterior Design and Styling Elements
The look of midsize SUVs is key in drawing in buyers. The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia stand out with their unique designs. They each have their own style that makes them special in the SUV market.
Body Dimensions
Looking at the body sizes shows how these SUVs differ:
| Dimension | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia |
|---|---|---|
| Length | 194.5 inches | 193.4 inches |
| Width | 76.0 inches | 75.5 inches |
| Height | 68.1 inches | 66.5 inches |
Available Color Options
Choosing colors can really change how a midsize SUV looks. There are many colors to pick from:
- Toyota Highlander Colors:
- Midnight Black Metallic
- Magnetic Gray Metallic
- Platinum White Pearl
- GMC Acadia Colors:
- Ebony Twilight Metallic
- Summit White
- Cayenne Red Metallic
Distinctive Design Features
The designs of these SUVs show off their brand’s unique look. The GMC Acadia has a strong, bold look with a big grille and sharp lines. On the other hand, the Toyota Highlander has a sleeker, more refined look that’s both stylish and useful.
Design is not just about appearance—it’s about creating an emotional connection with drivers.
Interior Comfort and Space
Interior comfort is key in midsize SUVs. The GMC Acadia and Toyota Highlander both have great cabin designs. They are perfect for families and those who love adventure.
Legroom is important for comfort. The GMC Acadia has a bit more space inside:
- Front row: 44.28 inches (Acadia) vs. 42.0 inches (Highlander)
- Second row: 41.45 inches (Acadia) vs. 38.7 inches (Highlander)
For big families, third-row seating is essential. Both vehicles provide third-row seating. The Acadia gives a bit more room for passengers. It also has flexible seating and cargo space.
Cargo space is also important. Both SUVs have good storage options. They can fold seats to make room for luggage, groceries, or gear.
Comfort isn’t just about space—it’s about how that space makes you feel during your journey.
Upholstery options range from cloth to premium leather. This lets drivers choose what fits their style and comfort needs. Both vehicles have ergonomic designs that make the cabin feel welcoming. This turns daily drives into enjoyable trips.
Highlander vs Acadia: Cargo Capacity Comparison
When comparing the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia, cargo space is key. Families and adventurers need versatile SUVs. Both vehicles offer impressive storage solutions for different lifestyles.
The cargo capacity between the Highlander and Acadia shows interesting differences. These differences can affect your buying choice. Let’s explore the storage capabilities of these popular SUVs.
Cargo Volume Breakdown
Here’s a detailed look at the cargo space for each vehicle:
- GMC Acadia:
- 23.0 ft³ with all seats in place
- Maximum 97.5 ft³ with second row folded
- Toyota Highlander:
- 16.0 ft³ with all seats in place
- Maximum 97.5 ft³ with second row folded
Flexible Storage Solutions
Both SUVs offer smart storage configurations. They help maximize cargo space. The Highlander and Acadia provide multiple seat-folding options. This allows drivers to adapt the interior for various cargo needs.
Practical Configurations
The seat folding mechanisms in these SUVs are designed for convenience. Drivers can quickly adjust seating for larger items. This makes these vehicles perfect for family road trips, moving furniture, or weekend adventures.
While the Acadia offers slightly more cargo space with seats up, both vehicles provide the same maximum cargo volume when the second row is folded. This gives consumers flexible options for their storage needs.
Technology and Infotainment Features
Modern SUVs are now all about their advanced infotainment systems. The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia offer top-notch tech for everyone in the car.
These vehicles showcase the latest in car tech. You’ll get smooth connectivity and easy-to-use interfaces. They make driving a whole new experience.
Key Infotainment System Features
- 8-inch touchscreen displays on both models
- Apple CarPlay® and Android Auto™ integration
- Wireless smartphone connectivity
- Advanced navigation systems
Each SUV has its own tech highlights. The GMC Acadia has a strong system with clear graphics and quick touch controls. The Toyota Highlander offers a system that’s easy to use.
| Feature | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia |
|---|---|---|
| Touchscreen Size | 8-inch | 8-inch |
| Smartphone Integration | Apple CarPlay® & Android Auto™ | Apple CarPlay® & Android Auto™ |
| Wireless Charging | Available | Available |
Drivers who love tech will enjoy the digital clusters and premium audio systems. These features make the car feel like a home theater. Both vehicles aim to keep you connected and entertained on every trip.
Safety Features and Ratings
When looking for an SUV, safety is key. The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia focus on keeping drivers and passengers safe. They use advanced safety technologies.
Standard Safety Equipment
These SUVs have strong safety features to prevent accidents. They include:
- Multiple airbag systems
- Anti-lock braking systems (ABS)
- Electronic stability control
- Tire pressure monitoring
- Rearview cameras
Advanced Driver Assistance Systems
Modern tech adds more safety to these SUVs. Advanced driver assistance systems make driving safer.
| Safety Feature | Toyota Highlander | GMC Acadia |
|---|---|---|
| Adaptive Cruise Control | Standard | Standard |
| Lane Departure Warning | Standard | Available |
| Automatic Emergency Braking | Standard | Standard |
The Highlander has Toyota Safety Sense™ 2.5+, and the Acadia has a full safety package. Both show their dedication to safety.
Ride Quality and Driving Experience
When comparing the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia, the driving performance is key. Both SUVs have unique features for different drivers and road types.
The Highlander offers a smooth ride with its suspension system. It performs well in cities and on highways, giving a comfortable ride. Drivers will find:
- Precise steering response
- Minimal road noise
- Balanced handling in various driving conditions
The GMC Acadia also has its strengths. It has an all-wheel-drive system for better traction and stability. Its features include:
- Responsive acceleration
- Confident cornering
- Enhanced weather adaptability
Driving fans will notice the performance differences between these SUVs. The Highlander focuses on comfort, while the Acadia is sportier. Each vehicle offers a unique driving experience for different tastes.
Choosing between the Highlander and Acadia depends on your driving style and what you expect from a vehicle.
It’s important to test drive both SUVs. This way, you can see which one fits your driving needs better.
Trim Levels and Available Options
Choosing the right trim level can change your driving experience. The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia offer various options. They match different tastes and budgets.
- LE: The base model with essential features and reliable performance
- XLE: Mid-tier trim featuring synthetic leather and upgraded displays
- XSE: Sporty design with performance-focused styling
- Limited: Near-luxury trim with premium interior details
Premium Features Breakdown
GMC Acadia also has compelling trim levels for different drivers:
| Trim Level | Key Features |
|---|---|
| SLT | Comfort-focused entry point with standard tech amenities |
| AT4 | Off-road-ready configuration with lifted suspension |
| Denali | Luxury-focused trim with premium finishes and advanced technology |
Package Options
Both the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia offer optional packages. These packages let you customize your SUV further. You can choose to enhance performance, add luxury, or improve utility.
Buyers can pick packages with advanced safety tech, premium sound systems, or special appearance upgrades. This flexibility means you can make your SUV exactly how you want it.
Maintenance Costs and Reliability
When looking at midsize SUVs like the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia, it’s important to think about long-term costs. Both vehicles have different ways of handling maintenance, which can affect your budget over time.
Toyota is known for making reliable midsize SUVs. The Highlander usually costs less to maintain than many others. Owners can look forward to:
- Predictable service intervals
- Widely available replacement parts
- Lower overall repair costs
The GMC Acadia has a different maintenance story. It’s generally reliable but might cost a bit more to keep up. Buyers should plan for:
- More frequent scheduled maintenance
- Potentially higher parts replacement expenses
- Slightly more complex service requirements
“Reliability isn’t just about avoiding breakdowns—it’s about predictable, manageable ownership experience.” – Auto Reliability Expert
Warranty coverage adds to the peace of mind. Toyota offers a 3-year/36,000-mile basic warranty and a 5-year/60,000-mile powertrain warranty. GMC also provides similar coverage, helping keep repair costs low in the first few years.
Choosing a reliable midsize SUV means looking at more than just the initial cost. It’s about the long-term maintenance commitment.
Off-Road Capabilities and Performance
The Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia have different ways to tackle tough terrain. Each SUV has its own strengths for adventurous driving. They go beyond just city and highway driving.
The GMC Acadia AT4 trim is known for its off-road features. It has a special all-wheel-drive system for better grip and stability. Its key features include:
- Specialized off-road suspension
- Advanced torque control AWD
- Increased ground clearance
- Intelligent terrain management system
The Toyota Highlander takes a more refined approach to off-roading. It’s not as specialized as the Acadia AT4 but is reliable. It offers:
- Predictable handling on varied terrain
- Snow and mud performance modes
- Hill descent control
- Adaptive suspension technology
Both SUVs are good for drivers facing tough weather or unpaved roads. The choice depends on what you value more. Do you want technical off-road skills or everyday driving ease?
Resale Value and Long-Term Ownership
When looking at SUVs as a long-term investment, resale value is key. The Toyota Highlander stands out for keeping its value well in the midsize SUV market. Its strong resale performance comes from being known for reliability and lasting long.
The GMC Acadia is a good alternative, but its resale value is not as high as the Highlander’s. Several things affect how well an SUV holds its value over time:
- Brand reputation for reliability
- Maintenance costs
- Market demand
- Overall vehicle condition
Toyota Highlander owners get:
- Lower depreciation rates
- High demand in the used car market
- Excellent build quality
- Proven track record of longevity
The GMC Acadia is a reliable SUV choice. Its resale value might not be as high as the Highlander’s. But, with good maintenance and careful driving, you can keep its value up.
Investing in a well-maintained SUV can significantly impact your long-term ownership experience and financial return.
When choosing between the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia, think about more than just the initial cost. Consider maintenance costs, fuel efficiency, and reliability history too.
Conclusion
Choosing between the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia needs careful thought. Both midsize SUVs have their own strengths. They cater to different needs and lifestyles.
The Highlander vs Acadia comparison shows key differences. Toyota is known for reliability and good resale value. GMC stands out for its style and advanced features. Buyers should think about family size, budget, and driving habits.
These SUVs are great choices for those wanting versatility and comfort. Each offers unique benefits, like fuel efficiency, safety, or interior space. Drivers should consider their needs to pick the best SUV for them.
It’s a good idea to test drive both the Highlander and Acadia. This way, you can see what makes each special. By comparing important features, you can make a choice that fits your needs.
FAQ
What is the starting price range for the Toyota Highlander and GMC Acadia?
The Toyota Highlander starts at around ,000-,000. The GMC Acadia starts at ,000-,000. Prices change based on features and options.
Which SUV offers better fuel efficiency?
The Toyota Highlander Hybrid gets up to 36 mpg in the city and 35 mpg on the highway. The standard GMC Acadia gets 21-26 mpg combined, depending on the engine.
How many passengers can each SUV accommodate?
Both SUVs can seat 7-8 people, depending on the trim and configuration. Seating can vary slightly by model year and trim.
Which SUV has better towing capabilities?
The GMC Acadia can tow up to 4,000 pounds when equipped. The Toyota Highlander can tow around 3,500 pounds, depending on the model.
Are there hybrid options available for these SUVs?
Yes, the Toyota Highlander has a hybrid option across many trims. The GMC Acadia does not have a hybrid, focusing on gasoline engines.
How do the safety ratings compare between the Highlander and Acadia?
Both SUVs get high safety ratings from NHTSA and IIHS. The Toyota Highlander has more standard safety features. The GMC Acadia also offers many safety technologies.
Which SUV offers more cargo space?
The Toyota Highlander has more cargo space, up to 84.3 cubic feet. The GMC Acadia has about 79 cubic feet of space.
What are the key differences in infotainment systems?
The Toyota Highlander uses the Entune system, while the GMC Acadia uses the GMC Infotainment System. Both have Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The Highlander’s system is often seen as more intuitive.
Which SUV is better for off-road driving?
The Toyota Highlander is better off-road, thanks to its all-wheel-drive and higher ground clearance. The GMC Acadia is better for on-road driving and city use.
What are the long-term reliability expectations for these SUVs?
Toyota Highlanders are known for their reliability, often ranking highest in dependability. The GMC Acadia has improved but doesn’t match the Highlander’s reliability and lower maintenance costs.
